property-location

159 Cat Town Rd Fly Creek, New York

4 bed • 2 bath • 10 guests

Purchase Price

Est. $NaN/mo

$79,647

Annual Revenue

Median of 25 comps selected by Adam, creator of this analysis.

Avg Daily Rate
$553
Occupancy
39%

$15k

$80k

$145k

$215k

Modern Hilltop Home With Stunning Vista Views
$212,383
$108,269
$905
64.3%
482642$300❌❌✅Yes / Yes❌⭐️ 4.97 (29)Profile
Pointe of View on Otsego Lake. 4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms 6 miles from Cooperstown
$169,050
$83,429
$870
53.2%
41013942$0❌❌❌Yes / Yes❌⭐️ 2.5 (18)

—

Beautiful Farmhouse w/ Heated Pool Game Room
$135,310
$26,985
$780
47.5%
4105463$300✅❌✅Yes / Yes❌⭐️ 5 (39)Profile
Beautiful Big Lake Front House W/gorgeous lake views
$124,627
$76,108
$503
67.9%
4124842$0❌❌✅Yes / Yes❌⭐️ 2.05 (14)

—

Mansion on lake with hot tub & stunning views.
$116,875
$52,223
$2,050
15.6%
41211683$450✅✅❌Yes / Yes❌⭐️ 5 (4)Profile
Loading amenity revenue opportunities

Seasonality

Break-even

$4,685/mo

Avg profit / month

$1,909/mo

Best profit month

Aug $8,951

Investment Value Over Time

Property Appreciation

3%

Revenue Appreciation

3%

Cash on Cash Return

27.44%

Cap Rate

13.2%

Profit (Cummulative)

$22,913

$3,487

$10,500

$10,647

$2,374

Total Gain

$39,421

BNBCalc Logo

Analyze an Airbnb Create Analysis

Products

Compare

Free Tools

Resources

Company

Legal


© 2026 BNB Calc, LLC. All rights reserved.

BNBCalc is an investment analysis tool, not a real estate brokerage or listing service. Properties displayed are not listed for sale or rent through BNBCalc. All property data, including addresses and revenue estimates, is sourced from publicly available records and third-party providers for analytical purposes only. Information is provided "as is" without any representation or warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy, completeness, or fitness for any purpose. Users should independently verify all data before making investment decisions. Content is for personal, non-commercial use only.