BNBCalc Short Term Rental Rental Arbitrage Analysis 720 Butler St # 16, Saugatuck, MI, 49453

3 bed • 4 bath • 9 guests • $0

BNB

Calc

Annual Revenue

$65,247

Profit (Cash Flow)

-$3,235

Cash on Cash Return

-35.5%

Annual Revenue

$65,247

AirDNA projects $538/night at 40% occupancy ($78,600). Airbtics projects $319/night at 56% occupancy ($65,247). Airbtics predicts this property will perform in the 46% revenue percentile

BNB Calc projects a 56% occupancy rate, $319 rate per night.

Revenue Percentile (property's earnings compare to others in the market}

Percentiles	25%	50%	75%	90%
Revenue	$46,415	$67,519	$87,394	$116,133
Occupancy	47%	58%	64%	75%
Nightly Rate	$264	$311	$362	$409

Seasonality (Profit by Month)

Airbnb Comparables

Airbnb name	Revenue	Rate/night	Occupancy	Beds	Baths	Night	Cleaning	Pool	Tub	Pets	W/D	Reviews
Lake Effect: Downtown eclectic former art gallery	$79,426	$365	59%	3	2	2	$202	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (37)
Ultra Lux Villa, Chic design, Hot Tub All Year Rou	$69,783	$323	58%	3	2.5	2	$200	❌	✅	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (100)
Located in Downtown Saugatuck with river views!	$64,185	$319	51%	3	3	1	$284	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (3)
Haven Suites Saugatuck-The Grand Suite	$89,582	$307	75%	3	2	1	$325	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (4)
Driftwood: Wrap Around Deck, Pet Friendly, Central	$54,644	$266	55%	3	2	1	$167	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (30)
Luxury Riverside Home near Oval Beach w/ Boat Dock	$59,578	$292	52%	3	2.5	7	$200	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (38)
Lady Bird Upstairs	$54,334	$279	51%	3	2	1	$225	❌	❌	❌	Y / N	⭐️ 5 (20)
Modern Cabin Getaway close to downtown Saugatuck!	$82,097	$412	51%	3	3	1	$394	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (12)
Nesting Nook	$85,035	$287	79%	3	3	3	$185	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (18)
Modern/ Fresh/ Lake View Condo Downtown Saugatuck	$38,878	$148	67%	3	2	1	$125	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (82)
Malaya Riverside	$43,694	$318	36%	3	3.5	3	$250	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (22)
Malabar: Downtown, Fire Pit, Porch, Pet Friendly	$53,022	$275	51%	3	2	1	$202	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (30)
Park Place: Riverfront, High-End, Walk to Beach	$64,036	$361	46%	3	2	1	$227	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (6)
Water Street Townhome Unit #6	$92,239	$358	69%	3	3.5	3	$250	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (15)
Downtown Saugatuck Condo w/deck - Pets are welcome	$44,049	$139	81%	3	2	1	$100	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (309)
Oval Beach Cabin by 500 acre wooded/dune preserve	$61,985	$292	58%	3	1	3	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (162)
Starry Night Cottage	$56,959	$248	62%	3	2	2	$125	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (145)
Charming Getaway Walking Distance to Downtown	$53,999	$316	45%	3	2	2	$149	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (38)
Lizzy's Place Saugatuck	$67,996	$330	55%	3	2	1	$285	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (7)
Hot tub! Firepit! Walk to Downtown. By Ivy House.	$74,829	$319	61%	3	2.5	1	$200	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (52)
Mid Century Meets Rustic Charm	$61,269	$259	64%	3	1.5	2	$100	❌	✅	❌	N / Y	⭐️ 5 (338)
Fresh pet friendly, central, 3 bed w hot tub.	$84,342	$394	58%	3	2	3	$175	✅	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (42)
Stunning Reno Near Downtown	$71,961	$409	35%	3	3	1	$499	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (5)
Secluded Cottage Getaway	$46,153	$192	64%	3	2	2	$195	✅	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (172)
Cozy Hideaway	$46,884	$306	38%	3	1.5	1	$250	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (13)
Spacious 3BR Lakeview Dog Friendly \| Hot Tub	$30,096	$355	22%	3	3	2	$283	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (41)
Sunsational: Hot Tub, Downtown, Porches, Pets Okay	$58,700	$354	44%	3	2.5	1	$202	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (48)
Harbor House: Upscale Waterfront Downtown Home	$65,689	$421	42%	3	3.5	1	$202	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (12)
Blue Whale	$66,662	$231	76%	3	2	1	$170	❌	❌	❌	Y / N	⭐️ 4.8 (80)
Peterson, Ravine, Open Concept, Cathedral Ceilings	$51,986	$212	67%	3	2	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (91)
skovhus - Walk to Oval Beach!	$148,237	$626	63%	3	2	5	$315	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (5)
Anna's Place, Ravine, Open Concept, High Ceiling	$52,264	$238	60%	3	2	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (68)
Modern Cabin, Secluded Yard, Year-Round Hot Tub!	$53,278	$260	53%	3	2	2	$199	❌	✅	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (88)
Downtown Condo - Butler Street	$62,274	$399	41%	3	4	2	$200	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (73)
A Step Away: Heart of Town / Partial River View	$148,704	$592	68%	3	4	2	$225	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (180)
Tate House	$59,521	$271	58%	3	2	2	$215	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (8)
Hidden Haven: Hot Tub, Screen Porch, Walk to Town!	$85,715	$295	79%	3	1.5	1	$157	❌	✅	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (49)
Saugatuck City-Stylish Mid-Century Modern-Sleeps 8	$70,639	$391	48%	3	2	2	$244	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (40)
Cozy home 2 miles from town; walk to Ivy House!	$60,778	$255	64%	3	3	3	$175	✅	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (46)
Aqua Essence: Water View, Swimming Pool, Downtown	$64,131	$377	46%	3	2.5	1	$182	✅	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (22)

Return Metrics

-35.54% cash on cash return is a poor return over the next 1 year

Cashflow Over Time

	Y1	Y2	Y3	Y4	Y5	Y10	Y30
Profit (Cummulative)	-$3,234	-$6,469	-$9,704	-$12,939	-$16,174	-$32,349	-$97,048
Revenue Appreciation	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0
Home Equity	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0
Down Payment	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0
Property Appreciation	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0
Total Return	-$3,234	-$6,469	-$9,704	-$12,939	-$16,174	-$32,349	-$97,048

Property Appreciation:

Revenue Appreciation:

Cash on Cash Return

-35.54%

Payback Period Days

Return on Investment

-35.54%

720 Butler St Saugatuck, Michigan, 49453

3 bed • 4 bath • 9 guests

Monthly Rent

Inquire about this property

Contact Agent

$65,247

Annual Revenue

BNBCalc predicts this property will get $319 per night with 56% occupancy, putting it in the top 46% revenue percentile compared to similar properties nearby.

Occupancy Rate

Top 56% of comparables

Avg Daily Rate

Top 44% of comparables

Seasonality

40 Airbnb Comparables

Adjust the filters to identify similar listings to yours. Then adjust your annual revenue estimate accordingly.

$66,990

Avg annual revenue

56%

Avg occupancy rate

$319

Avg nightly rate

🏊‍♂️ Pool

🛁 Hot tub

🐶 Pet friendly

Any type

House

Apartment

Any min stay

Weekly min

Monthly min

4.8+ stars

Revenue per year

$30k

$70k

$105k

$150k

-$3,235

Profit

Revenue

$65,247

Operating Expenses

$20,482

Operating Income

$44,765

Net Effective Rent

$48,000

Profit (Cash Flow)

-$3,235

$9,100

Cash Investment

Renos & Furnishing

$9,000

Setup Costs

$100

Total

$9,100

Investment Value Over Time

Revenue Appreciation

Cash on Cash Return

-35.54%

Payback Period Days