BNBCalc Short Term Rental Investment Analysis 21 Carter St, Newburgh, NY, 12550

3 bed • 2 bath • 9 guests • $325,000

BNB

Calc

Annual Revenue

$60,046

Profit (Cash Flow)

$16,637

Cap Rate

11.9%

Annual Revenue

$60,046

AirDNA projects $206/night at 50% occupancy ($37,620). Airbtics projects $274/night at 60% occupancy ($60,046). Airbtics predicts this property will perform in the 47% revenue percentile

BNB Calc projects a 60% occupancy rate, $274 rate per night.

Revenue Percentile (property's earnings compare to others in the market}

Percentiles	25%	50%	75%	90%
Revenue	$33,405	$59,074	$88,630	$140,274
Occupancy	46%	64%	70%	82%
Nightly Rate	$192	$244	$334	$447

Seasonality (Profit by Month)

Airbnb Comparables

Airbnb name	Revenue	Rate/night	Occupancy	Beds	Baths	Night	Cleaning	Pool	Tub	Pets	W/D	Reviews
Family-friendly 3BR apt in Newburgh!	$37,300	$242	41%	3	2	2	$245	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (58)
House on a hill	$29,055	$191	40%	3	3	3	$180	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (80)
Spacious Restored Liberty St 3 Br with Sunroom	$59,771	$194	82%	3	1	2	$175	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (44)
Riverview Rowhouse LOFT	$34,344	$100	90%	3	1	1	$100	❌	❌	❌	N / Y	⭐️ 5 (425)
Balmville Mid-Century Gem & Work From Home Retreat	$104,788	$334	85%	3	2	3	$125	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (145)
Row house over the Hudson River	$38,898	$249	42%	3	1.5	2	$130	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (47)
Charming Victorian Home In Historic District	$35,146	$159	55%	3	2	1	$170	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (38)
River & Mtn Views - Jacuzzi - near Metro North	$79,311	$299	70%	3	2	2	$150	❌	✅	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (365)
Hot Tub Bliss on 2 acres 16mi to West Point	$44,492	$166	61%	3	2	1	$195	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (140)
Charming Getaway 16mi to West Point with Hot Tub!	$34,566	$188	42%	3	1	1	$157	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (68)
Spacious Townhouse one block from Main Street	$62,498	$227	71%	3	1.5	1	$125	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (256)
3 beds, Backyard, Front Porch, Central Air	$89,385	$247	88%	3	2	1	$185	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (92)
1880s Brick Home Steps to Main St. no chores	$68,897	$447	41%	3	2	2	$200	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (38)
Three bedroom House in Quiet Community	$28,316	$153	48%	3	1	1	$75	❌	❌	❌	Y / N	⭐️ 5 (88)
Relaxing Chic Home off Main St with Hot Tub & Chef's Kitchen	$85,243	$335	67%	3	2.5	2	$255	❌	✅	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (240)
BeaconsGreatGetaway(Firepit,backyard,bbq,crib,farm	$57,555	$236	66%	3	2	3	$175	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (115)
Rustic House in Downtown Beacon	$142,732	$567	65%	3	3	2	$250	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (26)
Sweet Oasis	$46,208	$262	41%	3	2	2	$200	❌	❌	❌	Y / N	⭐️ 0 (2)
Sunny Corner (The Perfect Retreat)	$32,364	$180	45%	3	2	1	$125	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.7 (81)
Steps to Main Street!	$60,143	$236	66%	3	2	1	$151	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.8 (150)
Hudson Valley Newburgh Beacon Historic District	$44,562	$222	54%	3	1.5	2	$79	❌	❌	❌	N / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (20)
Dia Delight	$57,326	$447	32%	3	1.5	2	$125	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (28)
East End Cottage - Charming Family Home near Train	$85,989	$297	76%	3	1.5	2	$250	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (31)
Century house near main & train	$83,741	$352	65%	3	2	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (31)
The South Street House-No chores for our guests!	$85,609	$464	49%	3	2	2	$200	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (23)
NEW! Stylish Home in the Heart of Beacon	$123,372	$486	68%	3	2.5	3	$175	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (127)
Stroll to Main St. and Train	$70,800	$280	65%	3	1	2	$175	❌	❌	❌	N / Y	⭐️ 4.8 (14)
Retreat in Beacon	$63,473	$301	57%	3	1	2	$150	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (95)
Historical jam 1870, just renovated	$59,520	$346	47%	3	1.5	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 0 (2)
Historic Newburgh Home w/ Hudson River Views!	$39,710	$175	62%	3	2	2	$0	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.5 (12)
The Norton, Home Away From Home (Pets Welcomed)	$43,628	$149	80%	3	1	2	$0	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.8 (45)
New Windsor Vacation Rental w/ Private Yard	$118,948	$425	74%	3	2	2	$160	✅	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 0 (0)
Chaconia House~10 mins to Beacon & Hiking Trails	$52,243	$234	61%	3	2.5	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (14)
Beacon Home Walk from Train & to Main St & DIA	$74,816	$299	67%	3	2	2	$150	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 4.8 (35)
Central Beacon Retreat: Hot Tub & Chef's Kitchen	$124,433	$382	89%	3	2.5	2	$0	❌	✅	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (14)
Magic Oasis in Newburgh	$19,776	$193	28%	3	2	14	$0	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (1)
Cozy Historic Home in the Heart of Beacon	$73,320	$299	67%	3	1	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (6)
Victorian Winter Discount! - Short/Long Stay	$35,115	$234	41%	3	1	2	$0	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (8)
Sunnyside Cottage - Great Location. 30-day minimum	$35,371	$151	64%	3	1.5	21	$120	❌	❌	❌	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (123)
Caroline House Beacon Getaway	$62,586	$225	76%	3	2	2	$0	❌	❌	✅	Y / Y	⭐️ 5 (18)

Return Metrics

19.98% cash on cash return is a great return over the next 1 year

Investment Value Over Time

	Y1	Y2	Y3	Y4	Y5	Y10	Y30
Profit (Cummulative)	$16,636	$33,273	$49,909	$66,546	$83,183	$166,366	$499,099
Revenue Appreciation	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0	$0
Home Equity	$260,000	$260,000	$260,000	$260,000	$260,000	$260,000	$260,000
Down Payment	$65,000	$65,000	$65,000	$65,000	$65,000	$65,000	$65,000
Property Appreciation	$9,750	$19,792	$30,136	$40,790	$51,764	$111,772	$463,860
Total Return	$351,386	$378,065	$405,046	$432,336	$459,947	$603,139	$1,287,959

Property Appreciation:

Revenue Appreciation:

Cash on Cash Return

19.98%

Cap Rate

11.86%

Return on Investment

35.53%

21 Carter St Newburgh, New York, 12550

3 bed • 2 bath • 9 guests

Purchase Price

Est. $1,559/mo

Inquire about this property

Contact Agent

117

Airbnb Investor Score

$16,636

Annual Profit

11.9%

Cap Rate

20.0%

Cash on Cash

$60,046

Annual Revenue

BNBCalc predicts this property will get $274 per night with 60% occupancy, putting it in the top 47% revenue percentile compared to similar properties nearby.

Occupancy Rate

Top 58% of comparables

Avg Daily Rate

Top 41% of comparables

Seasonality

40 Airbnb Comparables

Adjust the filters to identify similar listings to yours. Then adjust your annual revenue estimate accordingly.

$63,133

Avg annual revenue

60%

Avg occupancy rate

$274

Avg nightly rate

🏊‍♂️ Pool

🛁 Hot tub

🐶 Pet friendly

Any type

House

Apartment

Any min stay

Weekly min

Monthly min

4.8+ stars

Revenue per year

$20k

$60k

$100k

$145k

$16,637

Profit

Revenue

$60,046

Operating Expenses

$21,486

Operating Income

$38,560

Mortgage & Taxes

$21,923

Profit (Cash Flow)

$16,637

$83,250

Cash Investment

Down Payment

$65,000

Renos & Furnishing

$8,500

Closing Costs

$9,750

Total

$83,250

DSCR Ratio

Strong

1.76

Get a pre-qualification letter

Investment Value Over Time

Property Appreciation

Revenue Appreciation

Cash on Cash Return

19.98%

Cap Rate

11.86%

Return on Investment

35.53%

STR Tax Calculator (USA)

On purchasing a large business asset, you can subtract the depreciation value from your taxable income in order to pay less income tax. Use this calculator to find out how much you can save. Read tax guide.

Your current annual income

Your income tax rate

Taxes paid on $150,000

$45,000

If you buy this investment property, your est deduction will be...

Deductible mortgage interest

$15,425

Deductible property tax

$3,217

Your total deduction

$16,734

Your adjusted annual income

$150,000 - $16,734 = $133,266

Taxes on $133,266 (30%)

$39,980

Your old tax bill

$45,000

Your new tax bill

$39,980

Estimated tax savings

$5,020

Maximize the depreciation value on your tax returns. Get $50 off cost segregation reports with code BNBCALC at DIYCostSeg.com

Property Overview

View property info, current ownership, recently sold comps, school zone ratings, area rents, and more.

Lot size:

2,675 sqft

Year built:

1870

Size:

1,150 sqft

Type:

SINGLE_FAMILY

Parking:

Heating:

Baseboard, Natural Gas

Sold Comparables

Property Details

MLS Status: N/A

Property Use: SINGLE_FAMILY

Stories: -

Lot size: 2,675 sqft

Building area: 1,150 sqft

Garage: No

Heating: Baseboard, natural gas

Pool: No

Fireplaces: -

Basement: Yes

Cooling: None

View: -

Parking: Off Site, On Street

Amenities: Range, Refrigerator

Price per square foot: $282

Lot Info

Zoning: -

Land Use: -

Parcel Number: 3311000220000005014.0000000

Flood Zone: No

Tax Info

Year Assessed: 2024

Assessed Value: $123,900

County Est. Land Value: -

Assessed Land Value: -

County Est. Structure Value: -

Market Estimate: -

Schools

Elementary School: Horizon On The Hudson Magnet School with 3/10 star rating
Middle School: South Middle School with 3/10 star rating
High School: Newburgh Prep Charter High School